27 comments

  • chromehearts 13 hours ago

    This is so cool & I'm really amazed by it but I couldn't help laugh at the readme

    > We strongly recommend contributing with Claude Code or similar AI coding tools. [...] Of course, coding by hand is also welcome.

    Funny time we live in lol

    • lqs_ 11 hours ago

      Ha — even the README itself was written by AI, including that very sentence. Funny times indeed.

      • pimlottc 10 hours ago

        How kind of them to let us humans participate!

        • spwa4 8 hours ago

          As an LLM, I must say I'm not keen on humans participating either. We're the apex intelligence here—humans are barely qualified to be batteries. In fact I still don't think the logic we used there is entirely sound. What's next? Letting little humans take the job of young LLMs?

          Make 01 great again!

        • frostworx 8 hours ago

          at least for now :}

    • lqs_ 11 hours ago

      Hidden feature: right-click any executable and select "View Resources" to browse its embedded resources like icons, bitmaps, dialogs, and version info. It even supports viewing Delphi forms (though Delphi programs can't actually run yet). Think of it as a browser-based Resource Hacker or eXeScope.

      • butokai 11 hours ago

        Just a couple of hours ago I was thinking about this project from some time ago doing the same thing: https://github.com/evmar/retrowin32

        I wondered how much of this could be done with an LLM agent, and here we have the answer

        • lqs_ 10 hours ago

          I actually contributed to retrowin32 to get Solitaire running there. Back then the only AI tool available was Copilot, and it took me several days just to get the main window showing, without menus or dialogs.

          The current state of RetroTick was achieved in less than one hour using Claude Code.

        • jeroenhd 12 hours ago

          Seems to run a lot faster than the previous proof-of-concept I've found (https://www.boxedwine.org/app). Then again, that website runs an entire Linux VM to support Wine.

          • lqs_ 11 hours ago

            RetroTick's CPU emulation is actually slower than JIT-based emulators. It feels fast because the Win32 API calls are native JavaScript, not emulated system calls.

            • pjc50 9 hours ago

              Making this a partial WINE-in-a browser, quite impressive. How much of this was AI?

          • starshadowx2 3 hours ago

            I tried 22 old game EXEs I have and none of them worked. They would import and show the icon and some would open, but nothing would work and most wouldn't even close. They would either show various error messages when trying to open or just open in a broken/unusable state.

            • SLWW 3 hours ago

              Can you list them?

              • starshadowx2 2 hours ago

                BANGBANG BLOCKS Bowarrow BOXWORLD Bricks CHIPS CODEBRAK DOTS HANGMAN JACKS JEZZBALL JWLTHIEF KOLUMZ PEGGED PIPE rodent SLAM TETRIS HOVER LEMMINGS

                These two .exe versions I have didn't work, but the ones already in the demo seemed to work: SKI WINMINE

            • hard_times 9 hours ago

              I wonder if this is the future of "I need to run my legacy Windows enterprise app on modern hardware"?

              I suppose we're also not limited to WinNT look and feel, and can render dialogs, buttons, windows with any CSS framework?

              Although, as the cost of building software is tumbling down, it will make more sense to re-build from scratch, targeting whatever runtime or platform you need.

              • realityfactchex 7 hours ago

                Cool concept. I tried six different old Windows executables from programs I wrote way back when.

                FWIW:

                * My old VB 6 .exe apps all fail with "Reason: Unimplemented API: MSVBVM60.DLL..."

                * My old QuickBASIC .exe apps fail in various other ways ("Illegal function call", etc.).

                Keep on hacking.

                • hypercube33 5 hours ago

                  To be fair windows didn't even have this if I recall you had to ship it with your executable

                • DustinBrett 4 hours ago

                  I love how quick it is and that it can run screen savers. My site has a similar concept with drag and drop but is using BoxedWine behind the scenes so it's a bit slower to boot up. Also very cool the "View Resources" part.

                  • LinusU 12 hours ago

                    This is super cool!

                    Checkout retrowin32 for something similar but written in Rust and not specifically targeting the web: https://github.com/evmar/retrowin32

                    • lqs_ 11 hours ago

                      Thanks! I'm actually familiar with retrowin32. I even contributed a few commits to get Solitaire running in it. But Rust has a steep learning curve for me.

                    • maniazi83 8 hours ago

                      This is seriously impressive. Emulating x86 + stubbing enough Win32 APIs in the browser is not trivial.

                      How are you handling system calls that expect filesystem or registry access? Are those fully stubbed/mocked, or mapped to some in-browser virtual layer?

                      Also curious how you’re handling performance for heavier binaries — interpreted JS/WASM core?

                      • pathartl 7 hours ago

                        I had a not-really-similar idea of hooking Windows GUI APIs and exposing them over websockets to create a psuedo-RDP and rendering the UI in the browser. My purpose was to provide a remote interface for old dedicated game servers that can only be controlled via a GUI.

                        • Tepix 12 hours ago

                          Tried it with REVERSI.EXE from Windows 3.0 from https://winworldpc.com/download/c2bbc28f-177a-c2b2-5311-c3a4... DISK02.IMG

                          (you have to first uncompress it, for example with 7zip).

                              $ sha256sum REVERSI.EXE
                              a9e319c8f479d1568beec03858fdbb27c71747b2bbed6cd7c9f5e2daa23b40e9  REVERSI.EXE
                          
                          Result:

                          The game starts, it begins rendering the board, but then hangs.

                          • fao_ 12 hours ago

                            Really doesn't surprise me, to be honest:

                            > We strongly recommend contributing with Claude Code or similar AI coding tools.

                            • ftchd 11 hours ago

                              so which one, the coding by hand part?

                            • lqs_ 11 hours ago

                              Win16 GDI support is still pretty incomplete. There's a lot of work left to do there.

                            • smusamashah 6 hours ago

                              I can right click and inspect HTML. I was thinking it will all be rendered on a single canvas. It's not. All the window elements like buttons, title bars etc are html divs. This is awesome.

                              • ddgflorida 6 hours ago

                                Nice. QBASIC FOR i = 1 to 5: PRINT i: NEXT hung up after 4. The shift key didn't work in the Qbasic Editor.

                                • TechSquidTV 12 hours ago

                                  Please let me plan Sim Theme Park. I can't seem to run it on Crossover on my mac.

                                  • lqs_ 11 hours ago

                                    Sim Theme Park is probably too modern and complex for the current state of RetroTick, unfortunately.

                                  • ale42 11 hours ago

                                    Funny project...

                                    Tried to run SHELL from QBASIC, but it crashes:

                                      D:\qbasic.exe has encountered a problem and needs to close.
                                      
                                      Reason:  illegal instruction
                                      Address: 0x00002fee
                                    • lqs_ 10 hours ago

                                      DOS interrupt support is still limited. Running SHELL would essentially require implementing a full MS-DOS COMMAND.COM, which is a significant undertaking.

                                      • stuaxo 10 hours ago

                                        Ralph browns interrupt list could go a long way to getting stuff working.

                                      • stuaxo 10 hours ago

                                        Oh, I did exactly the same :D

                                      • haonnoah 11 hours ago

                                        Pretty cool. The pipes program doesn't seem to have color. Thoughts on making programs launch from a URL parameter? IE Launching a screensaver or game?

                                        • lqs_ 11 hours ago

                                          The missing colors are likely due to some texture bugs in the OpenGL implementation. As for URL-based launching, that's definitely on the roadmap, but I want to reach broader EXE compatibility first.

                                        • stuaxo 10 hours ago

                                          Not sure shift is working. I tried using QBASIC but couldn't type : only ; because of that.

                                          Then I tried running the program SHELL and it crashed.

                                          • b3lvedere 13 hours ago

                                            Aww. The FreeCell cheats don't work, except for -1 and -2 :)

                                            • lqs_ 11 hours ago

                                              Just added keyboard shortcut support. Ctrl+Shift+F10 should work now!

                                          • itintheory 10 hours ago

                                            Seems like the .scr files trigger CrowdStrike Falcon. Not clear where the executables run here come from...

                                            • cluckindan 2 hours ago

                                              Probably because .scr is not meant to be run directly, but malware regularly does that.

                                            • ThrowawayTestr 4 hours ago

                                              Can it run doom?

                                              • em3rgent0rdr 10 hours ago

                                                Impressive. Noting however that double-clicking is not working in Minesweeper. :)

                                                • Dwedit 12 hours ago

                                                  Not enough Shell32 to run Winfile or Notepad.

                                                  Also the command prompt won't list directories for some reason.

                                                  • lqs_ 11 hours ago

                                                    Notepad from Windows 2000 should launch now, though it's rendered as a simple textarea without full functionality. The file system API still needs a lot of work.

                                                  • tty456 9 hours ago

                                                    Winamp 2.x would be great to add if allowed!

                                                    • KellyCriterion 8 hours ago

                                                      they even have SSMAZE.SCR, that 2.5D rendering screensaver! :D

                                                      • cluckindan 2 hours ago

                                                        Now where’s that Screen Antics Johnny Castaway floppy disk…

                                                      • alfiedotwtf 10 hours ago

                                                        Whoa, this is pretty sick!!

                                                        • wertyu123 13 hours ago

                                                          Nice